Big news this morning about Christine Brashear, who is currently with Samhain Publishing and was previously a part of Ellora’s Cave. Ms. Brashear is filing suit against EC and its shareholders. Not being of a legal mindset, I don’t understand it enough to comment on it but you can read about the whole thing at Smart Bitches and Dear Author.
Both sites explain it much better than I could, and I have to admit, I payed more attention to the comments than I did to the actual blog posts. There are comments from readers, from authors, and some from people who understand far better than I what’s going on, but the thing that stood out for me is the way some of these commenters behave–trashing SB or DA for blogging about this, saying a lawsuit is private and shouldn’t be brought to the public’s attention, etc. Same old, same old, was my first take…until I took a minute to think about it.
This kind of behavior holds true for almost all the news stories that these blogs report on, whether it be about the Cassie Edwards thing, or New Concepts treating their authors badly, or an author acting like an idiot. There’s always someone who pops up and disses the site for the post and in most cases, the disser(s) turn downright mean–even if they didn’t start out that way.
The thing is…I’ve heard some derogatory comments that the reason all this trouble crops up with e-publishers is because the majority of e-publishing companies are owned by women and everybody knows women are driven by their hearts rather than their minds. They’re too emotional and don’t have the balls to make it in the business world. <eye roll>
I take exception to that because I know when Twilight Fantasies went down, it was the male half of the partnership who gave me the most trouble. His name calling, finger pointing, and all-around childish behavior, were the epitome of unprofessional behavior. In the end, it was the woman who stood up and addressed the problems, sending professional rights reversion letters to the authors. And when she did, the man, well, he faded away as if he’d never been there at all.
After all that, I’ve decided that I’d much rather deal with a female in a situation like this. And while the overwhelming femaleness of e-publishing may not be a good thing at times, I think it’s definitely going to be a plus in the long run. Women are still in the infant stage when it comes to being business owners and they have a double challenge when it come to e-publishing because it too is still a baby. But nurturing is one of the things we’re really good at. We’re not afraid to clean up a mess or tackle a seemingly hopeless cause or to dole out the proper discipline when it’s needed.
And I think that’s exactly what sites like SB, DA, Karen Knows Best, EREC, and yes, I’ll throw Piers Anthony in there too–even though he is a <gasp> man–are doing, they’re policing the e-publishing industry with a loving heart and a gentle, guiding hand backed up with a sharp slap to the butt when it’s needed.
I hope every author out there who writes for an e-publisher remembers to thank them for it one day.





7 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 9, 2008 at 12:07 AM
Shiloh Walker
Caitlyn, I haven’t read as much on the SB’s board about this, but in general, I don’t think the commenters at the DA blog are slapping at DA so much as saying that it’s between CB and EC’s authors.
That’s how I view this~it’s between Crissy Brashear and EC’s owners. Newsworthy? Yeah, but just a lot of people are interested doesn’t mean I really want to discuss it.
Chances are it has authors tense. I write for both of them. I definitely want to know what comes of this.
But I’m not going to speculate over it. I’d recommend, and already have, that authors of both places just let it stay between the involved parties. Nothing good will come from us (the involved publishers’ authors) getting involved. Just my opinion, but I think that’s where many of the comments on the DA board are stemming from.
April 9, 2008 at 3:25 PM
caitlynhunter
I agree, this is between Brashear and EC’s owners, but it is news and I commend DA and SB for posting about it. And yes, there were a few commenters who called Jane to task for posting about it, saying (among other things):
“Just because one former employee of Ellora’s Cave has a beef with the company is no reason to slam mud at either Brashear or the principals at Ellora’s Cave.”
I don’t know about you, but I consider the “slam mud” part of that comment a slap at DA for posting about something that is, as Jane says in her response, “completely newsworthy.”
Anyway, what I was getting at here (and I apologize for not stating it clearly enough, I just came back from vacation and I think I left my brain behind in Florida!) is we need sites like DA, SB, etc. Also, the fact that women being the predominant force in in the e-publishing business is a good thing, rather than a bad thing as so many people have said.
Once again, sorry for not making it clear, and btw, I think this is no more than a tiny blip on EC’s radar, nothing for the authors to worry about or as you say, even get involved in.
Caitlyn
April 11, 2008 at 3:30 AM
shilohwalker
I can’t disagree. We definitely do need them.
April 11, 2008 at 3:49 PM
RfP
“Just because one former employee of Ellora’s Cave has a beef with the company is no reason to slam mud at either Brashear or the principals at Ellora’s Cave.”
I took that comment as a response to some real mud-slinging and panic that was happening in the comments. Some commenters seized the opportunity to air their grievances with Ellora’s Cave and with Christine B.
In a different vein a few commenters feared Ellora’s Cave might fold, or assumed that this lawsuit meant Ellora’s Cave was one of the “bad guys” of e-publishing. Some of that strikes me as tarring Ellora’s Cave with the same brush as, say, Triskelion–which doesn’t make sense, as the scales of the businesses AND the legal issues are completely different. In that regard, I agree with “Just because one former employee… has a beef with the company…”. As you say, so far it doesn’t sound like anything that should affect authors or readers.
April 11, 2008 at 4:02 PM
caitlynhunter
Oh, I know what you mean, Shiloh. I’ve pulled way too many late nighters since I got back from vacation, but there’s just so much going on right now with Amazon, DAM, and several e-pubs behaving like idiots. I get sucked in and forget about the time!
And it doesn’t help that my muse is canoodling on the beach with the hero of my current WIP, and it doesn’t look like they’re thinking of coming back anytime soon!
Caitlyn
April 11, 2008 at 4:27 PM
caitlynhunter
“I took that comment as a response to some real mud-slinging and panic that was happening in the comments. Some commenters seized the opportunity to air their grievances with Ellora’s Cave and with Christine B.”
Hmm, I never thought of it that way, but if I remember correctly, that comment was the second one posted–at least at DA, don’t know about SB. Still, you have a point, and it didn’t take long for the EC naysayers to come out, but like I said in an earlier comment, I really don’t think this will be anything more than a tiny blip on EC’s radar–if that!
Thanks for commenting and…well, I won’t thank you for giving me another blog to read, but I clicked on yours and let’s just say it caught my interest. At this rate, I’m never going to get any writing done.
Caitlyn
April 15, 2008 at 11:56 AM
RfP
You may be right–sometimes I have trouble keeping straight which conversation happened on which site.
Thanks : )